Advertisement

HC asks BMC to strictly follow 11pm deadline for neon lights

The court's directions have brought renewed attention to the need for stricter enforcement of existing restrictions and comprehensive measures to address urban light pollution.

HC asks BMC to strictly follow 11pm deadline for neon lights
SHARES

The Bombay High Court has directed the Brihanmumbai Municipal Corporation (BMC) to strictly enforce a February 1998 order requiring neon lights to be switched off by 11 pm. The direction was issued on Friday while hearing a petition highlighting increasing light pollution caused by high-intensity floodlights, illuminated billboards and other artificial lighting installations across Mumbai and Thane. 

A division bench comprising Chief Justice Mahesh Chandra Tripathi and Justice Advait Sethna also directed the Maharashtra government to file an affidavit responding to the concerns raised. The matter has been scheduled for further hearing on November 20. The petition was filed by Nilesh Desai, a wildlife and astrophotography enthusiast, who has raised concerns over excessive artificial illumination affecting residential areas and public spaces. Particular attention has been drawn to "light trespass", a phenomenon in which powerful artificial lighting spreads beyond its intended area, causing inconvenience to surrounding residents.

Floodlights installed at gymkhanas along Marine Drive have been specifically highlighted in the petition. It has been alleged that these lights remain operational late into the night, disturbing residents and affecting their sleep. Concerns have also been raised about brightly illuminated billboards in commercial areas, including Bandra Kurla Complex, where excessive glare can create difficulties for motorists. The petition has further highlighted the potential health and environmental consequences of prolonged exposure to artificial lighting. It has been argued that excessive brightness can contribute to headaches, migraines, visual fatigue and disrupted sleep patterns. The natural behaviour of animals and plants dependent on regular daylight and darkness cycles may also be affected.

Energy conservation has been identified as another significant concern. According to the petition, appropriate lighting solutions could reduce energy consumption by approximately 60% to 70%, thereby limiting unnecessary electricity usage and conserving natural resources.

Desai has reportedly submitted more than 100 complaints to police authorities and district collectorate offices seeking action against high-intensity lighting. However, it has been alleged that effective measures have not been implemented despite repeated representations. The petition, filed through advocate Ronita Bhattacharya Bector, has also raised road safety concerns, arguing that excessively bright lights can distract drivers and create hazardous conditions. 

A dedicated regulatory framework similar to the Noise Pollution Rules has been sought to establish permissible lighting levels, operating hours, penalties for violations and a public grievance mechanism. Desai has additionally proposed a 10 pm deadline for switching off high-intensity lights and requested the formation of a committee comprising senior government officials to examine the issue.

The court's directions have brought renewed attention to the need for stricter enforcement of existing restrictions and comprehensive measures to address urban light pollution.

Read this story in हिंदी
RELATED TOPICS
MumbaiLive would like to send you latest news updates